Gastric LAP-BAND® Surgery
Thumbs up from this Dietitian
for Stomach Band Surgery

A dietitian's thoughts on gastric LAP-BAND® surgery.

I remember the skepticism I received when I first started telling my friends and family that I was interested in working with stomach band surgery.

"What?!" They exclaimed...

..."you believe in the gastric banding procedure?!...I thought you were a strong proponent of diet and exercise to lose weight?!"

I am, I replied. And I always will be. However, I'm too aware of the statistics to ignore gastric LAP-BAND® surgery as a viable option.

It's well known that morbid obesity is a serious disease associated with a number of life-threatening illnesses that can be improved with sufficient weight loss. However...

Although many people lose weight temporarily with diet, exercise, pharmacotherapy, and/or behavior modification, research has demonstrated that fewer than 5% of all dieters lose a significant amount of weight and maintain that weight loss over a 5 year period.

Furthermore, according to research, 90% of all dieters regain some or all of the lost weight and at least 1/3 even gain even more.

These aren't easy statistics for me to stomach. I've been working for 19 years as a dietitian trying to help people lose weight and improve their health through diet, exercise, and behavior modification. The statistics suggest that my life's work will positively impact less than 5% of my patients.

Pretty depressing. In fact, these statistics could easily throw me into the mid life crisis I've been flirting with if I were to let them!

I've spent the last 19 years of my life devoted to helping people lose weight. Have I been wasting my time?

Should I continue to hold on to the hope and belief that weight loss success is possible when the odds suggest just the opposite?

Enter the research about gastric LAP-BAND® surgery.

  • There's research showing stomach band patients typically lose 50-60% of excess weight over 5 years.
  • Resolution or improvement has been seen in 90% or more of gastric band patients with asthma, type 2 diabetes, sleep apnea, and gastroesophageal reflux disease (GERD).

If a person has a 90% or greater chance of resolving or improving type 2 diabetes, asthma, sleep apnea or GERD as a result of having stomach band surgery, when they have a slim to none chance of losing weight on their own and never resolving those health issues, why wouldn't a gastric banding procedure be a viable option?

Think about it...

...If you had cancer (G-d forbid) and your doctor said, "I have 2 treatment options for you:

One has a 95% failure rate. The other has a 90% success rate.

Which treatment option would you choose?

That being said...

How I ultimately feel about weight loss and bariatric banding

I will continue to believe until my dying day that weight loss is possible through diet, exercise, and behavior modification. I will continue to believe that any one of my clients has the potential to be one of the 5% who actually does achieve and sustain weight loss in this way.

At the same time I believe it's possible, I accept that it's not probable.

That being the case, I support the decision of those who opt for gastric LAP-BAND® surgery and am committed to educating you and sharing my experience as a gastric band dietitian so that you get the best results possible from your gastric LAP-BAND® surgery.

More of My Professional Advice You May Find Useful

Everything You Need to Know About Diet After Stomach Band Surgery

Gastric LAP-BAND® Surgery Overview

Home Page

Enjoy this page? Please pay it forward. Here's how...

Would you prefer to share this page with others by linking to it?

  1. Click on the HTML link code below.
  2. Copy and paste it, adding a note of your own, into your blog, a Web page, forums, a blog comment, your Facebook account, or anywhere that someone would find this page valuable.